Sirman's Report on Florianopolis & Sao Paulo (Brazil). 2005
Plus Essay about Languages, (rather Tribal Sounds)
Close this page when done
========================================================= Sent from Sao Paulo, Brazil on Dec. 25 Hey guys, I am about done with my Brazil tour. Arrived at the bus station in Sao Paulo, where I will stay until my flight back home on Dec. 26/27. I should add that I did the entire one-month trip without speaking a word of Portuguese or Spanish, though by now I know several words, and understand--reading--much more. I met only a handful of Brazilians who could stutter in English, some spoke nicely, but none at ticket counters or info desks. I relied on the native intelligence of the people, for example, saying the name of my next destination and showing my watch, meaning ?when is the next bus to such and such place?? Seeing that I could not understand the local language, the person wrote down the time(s) and the price, and that was that, as I had done also in Ukraine, Belarus, etc. Let me give you my view of languages. 1. Languages. I grew up with Turkish, then changed to German, attending junior high at an Austrian boarding school, later even more exclusively in Germany as I attended high school. By then I could speak German as well as Germans. All that effort was wasted when I arrived in USA started English, as I took my classes at the university. I began to realize that while I was tri-lingual, much of my memory cells in effect were filled with vocabulary, grammar, der-die-das clutter I no longer needed. German is translated so well into English that indeed I could read Goethe?s Faust in English and not lose much on nuances. And as I delved deeper into English, while making a silent resolution that I would not learn another language, I noticed that my fluency in German declined, though I could read almost as well as before. I put my resolution into effect in Arabia. 5 years there and I made almost no effort into learning Arabic. All my work was exclusively in English, and I did not need elaborate Arabic outside. That others could speak a few words in English was sufficient for most needs. It did not bother me that I could not tell or understand jokes in Arabic. The world was getting smaller, globalization taking hold, the Internet connecting world, and English was becoming the International language. As time passed and I became a world traveler, much of the useless der-die-das in my memory was now replaced with places like Kigoma, Tanzania and Mpulungu, Zambia--ends of Lake Tanganyika--which was OK. When I was in Africa in 2005, I took many bus thru about a dozen countries, in a span of about 14 days, I was the only white among the natives. I noticed that people from one region spoke a dialect unique to them, that people in the adjoining region did not quite understand them, for they had their own dialect. If the 2 regions wanted to talk to each other, they used Afrikaans in the south, Swahili in the north, in effect making these 2 languages into a bridge for Africa-wide communication, much like English on the International arena. I thought of how English, French, German, etc. took hold in different parts of Europe, one group using the word GUGU for this, the next group using GAGA for the same, JUJU in some other part. As these became higher civilizations, the speakers of JUJU became French, those who uttered GAGA English, ones with GUGU German, no different than what I was witnessing in Africa in 2005: tribal sounds. When you visit Latin countries, one of the first things you will notice is language schools advertised all over the place. And apparently enough idiots enroll in these classes to make them popular money-makers, for you have to pay for them, not to mention take time off from travel to attend the classes. As most travel books underline, the native cultures are supposedly delighted if a visitor makes an attempt to stutter in their native tongue, AS IF this makes them part of this tribe. I think otherwise. Here I am taking a month of, and incurring substantial costs, to come and visit this country, indeed circle the whole place as if a native (I was the only tourist in almost all the buses I took), and all this did not suffice BUT stuttering a few words in the native tongue would do the trick. NONSENSE. To me the only reason a visitor needs to learn the local language is if this person is studying that language, doing research related to something about this country, or something of that kind. Otherwise, instead of expecting ME, a passing tourist, to take classes and waste my travel time and fun, and pay for this besides, it would be much easier for the Government of that country to find a native person adequate in English, tell that person that he/she would not need to translate a book but be merely be prepared to give basic info to foreigners--also Europeans and other travelers, who are generally good in English--to make their travel easier. This is what hospitality is all about. So if I DONT find such an office and person, as in Kaliningrad, Belarus, Ukraine, Russia, Latin America, and other places, this conveys to me that this Government/country does NOT really VALUE ME as a visitor, that I am seen merely as a hard currency provider. This also means that I will not make the effort to learn the language of such a society. Besides, I have now traveled thru 123 countries. By this logic, I would have had to learn say about 200 too 300 of the GUGUs and GAGAs (words) of say 100 tribes. 2. Tourist Set-up in Brazil. Except for the lack of English, I found Brazil very well set up for tourists and backpackers, perhaps as good as South Africa and Australia, of course much superior to the USA--due to very bad public transport in USA. (Indeed, the only sensible way of doing USA is to arrive with 3 friends--to share costs--rent a car for say 6 weeks to 2 months, and circle the country, stopping at hostels where you can find them.) As for the long-distance bus system, if the Intercape buses in South Africa and Namibia are the best in the world, the ones in Brazil would rate as 2nd. It has 3 classes: Executive, Leito, and Conventional. Even in the latter, there is ample leg room and the seats are comfortable, though a bit tight sideways. The price is cheaper than comparable buses in Mexico and Turkey, perhaps also than the ones in South Africa. Hostels exit not just in large cities, several in bigger ones, but even in villages. I liked Brazil, though I wish more people spoke English, especially at bus stations and info desks. It is difficult to imagine that in a reasonable advanced country like Brazil, people look at you as if they never heard there is a language called English. 3. Add Florianopolis to your Brazil list. Several natives mentioned that Florianopolis is perhaps the MOST livable city in Brazil. After using one coupon flight to Manaus, taking the ship to Belem, flight to Salvador, flight to Campo Grande (for Pantanal), bus/flight to Iguazu for the falls and Itaipu Dam, use your last coupon (or take the 15-hour bus, as the roads are a bit better in the south) to Florianopolis on the Atlantic coast, if you want to see ONE beach-town. Fortaleza is nice too and has beaches 3 hours south and north, but I liked Florianopolis the best as it packs all in one site. It is actually an island 54km long (North-South) and 18km wide. So from either the mainland or the island the other shore looks as if you are on the Bosporus in Istanbul, even the villages remarkably similar. Yet, there are so many beaches and lagoons, etc, that parts of the vista also resembles that of San Diego, though from close-up the architecture is more that of resorts in Turkey. Wait till I post some photos and post cards. Florianopolis is in the State of Santa Catarina, just south of the state Parana with the city of Iguazu on the west and Curitiba on the east. (We passed Curitiba on the way.) There is luggage-check and info desk at the bus station--no Internet. For sight-seeing in one day take a city bus from the city bus terminal about 200m to the right as you exit the long-distance terminal. a) From Terminal B, take Bus 311 to Lagoa da Conceicao, change (at the end of line) to Bus 360 to Barra da Lagoa, all (20-min scenic ride) in one ticket for 2.30 Real ($1). Walk around a bit to get a feel for the place, village. Get back to the terminal the same way. For northern and southern parts of the island use buses at Terminal C and D. b) to south: Bus 410 or 430 connecting to 563 (2:75 Real, 30 min), c) to north: Bus 210. The scenery varies from very quaint to spectacular, all in a sub-tropical setting. 4. Minas Gerais (State) out, Sao Paulo in. After Florianopolis I was going to take a bus north to Belo Horizonte, state capital of Minas Gerais, said to be a pretty state, north of the State of Sao Paulo. But then I decided against it. I have already covered 19 of the 27 Brazilian states in this huge land, among them the most interesting ones. So instead, I took the 10:30pm bus to Sao Paulo and arrived at 8am next morn (Dec. 24), to give myself a day or 2 of sight-seeing, in this Brazil?s largest city, before my midnight flight back to USA on Dec. 26/27. 5. Sao Paulo, Bus Station to Hostel. Sao Paulo is at least 3 times larger than Paris, a lot of it haphazard, with many favelas--ghetto-like places--on hillsides. But, of course, there are also nicer parts. When you arrive at the long-distance bus station in TIETE, the small tourist info counter is next to a garden-like patio. It was closed when I arrived, but I got a metro map and a downtown city map. Look around for the escalator to one floor up. Turn left and walk straight ahead to the metro ticket counter and pay 2.10 Reals for the one-time ticket. You are on the Blue Line here. Look for the sign to JABAQUARA, the end destination of that line. Get on the metro and get off at the 5th stop at SE to change to the RED line to BARRA FUNDA. Get off the metro at the 2nd stop at REPUBLICA. Here You will take 3 separate elevators. There are 3 separate exits. Take the one to Rua do AROUCHE--make a U after the 3rd escalator, walk about 100m, then take the 4th elevator to street. MARK this SPOT. To your left is the Republic Square, just 20m away across the street. 15m from you just around the corner is also the bus to the airport (24 Reals), the ticket office also right there. This is also the direction you will walk for sight-seeing all the way to the cathedral and justice building just past the SE station. However, to get to the hostel, you will turn right and walk about 100m to the next big x-street with park-like Largo do AROUCHE as center lane on that street. Stay on the right sidewalk, cross the street to AROUCHE park, keep the FLOWER Market to your right, also passing the huge (banyan-tree-size) rubber tree, and continue straight until you come to a circle. Circle the circle from left to the other side and look right across at the 7-story yellow building with orange trim. (The brown building, Hotel SAN MICHEL, will be on the left corner.) The yellow building is the Downtown HI Hostel Sao Paulo. This is not the best or liveliest neighborhood, but you are at the center of the city. The entry is on the first street to the left as you come to the building. a) At the Hostel. 4-bed dorms go for 27 Reals (25 for members) with breakfast, sheets and towel included. There is a smoking patio on the 7th floor; Internet ($ Reals per hour) and breakfast are on 1st floor. By the way, you can pay your bill by credit card at this and all other hostels, but here they do not accept Dollars--too many fake ones--whereas all others, in fact, give you change for Dollars. b) Walking Tour. The hostel has a 3-hour walking tour for 20 Reals. Since I was there on Christmas there was no tour. You can take the tour on your own. Everything you want to see is reached by turning left at Pra(ch)a Republica where you got off to get to the hostel. The map from the hostel is too detailed. Get a map of touristic sites from the Info kiosk at the other side of Republic Square. Most of this area is pedestrian on weekends. Walk to SE Square, reach the cathedral, and circle the block in front of the ornate justice building. If you want to see also the most exclusive street in Sao Paulo in the JARDIM PAULISTA nearby, enter the SE Metro Station, take the BLUE Line in JABAQUARA destination and get of at PARAISO (4th Stop), walk across the platform to the GREEN Line in the direction of MADALENA, get off at the 2nd exit at BRIGADERO, turn right after getting off the metro, and walk to AV PAULISTA exit. I did not find this street particularly interesting, 4 lanes going this way, 4 in the opposite direction, a center divider with light posts and trees, framed by tall commercial buildings. If you want, make u-turn after the escalator to the street, and walk 2 metro stations to CONSOLA(CH)AO, then reverse your steps to return, now taking the GREEN line in the direction of ANA ROSA, getting off at Paraiso to BLUE Line to TUCURIVI, getting off at SE, and if you had enough of Sao Paulo, continuing on RED Line to BARRA FUNDA and getting off at Republica, as you did from the bus station, and walking back to the hostel. You are done with the best of Sao Paulo. (IN Rio you would have needed at least 3 days: 1) for Corcovado and Sugar loaf, 2) City tour, getting off the bus in Ipanema and walking back thru Ipanema to Copacabana, perhaps all the way to the Meridian Hotel on the beach side, returning on the sidewalk side, with a stop at Maxim for a beer and people-gazing, 3) taxi to the China (or Chinese) point.) Sirman